File an Insurance Claim

We know that if you need to file an insurance claim, you are already stressed and upset. That's why our team at John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency created this online claim tool to help. With this tool, you'll be able to file your claim 24/7, 365 days a year. As soon as we digitally receive your claim, we will begin working on your case to get you the best possible outcome. Fill out the information required below to send your claim to us.

NOTE: If you have a claim to report, please contact our agency first at 614-729-8335 to help you get started. If you need to file a claim after hours or over the weekend, you can contact ERIE's 24/7 Claim Support Service directly.

WEBSITE: Claims

CLAIMS: (800) 367-3743

AFTER HOURS CLAIMS: (800) 367-3743

24/7 ROADSIDE SERVICE (AGERO): (888) 295-5060

ERIEGLASS (AUTO GLASS ONLY): (800) 552-3743

FRAUD FINDERS (TO REPORT FRAUD): (800) 368-6696