teenSMART® safety training that pays off
Smarter driving skills today can mean savings tomorrow.
Get Started
John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency specializes in auto, home, business, and life insurance.
Insuring Reynoldsburg, Pickerington, and the General Columbus, Ohio Area
At Neighbarger Insurance, our priority is helping our customers find the best coverage in order to protect what matters most in life. As an Independent agency, we work with a wide variety of top carriers to help you find the best coverage to suit your exact situation.
No matter your insurance needs, we can help you find the perfect policy to give you peace of mind without breaking the bank.
Our Insurance Products
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Customer Reviews
Very friendly and professional with low rates as well.
MB
mike b
Very easy to work with.
AJ
Amy J Stebelton
Quick service, very professional.
MW
Michael W
Mr. Neighbarger has been my insurance agent for over 20 years.
AB
A B
Highly recommend John's office.
MS
Mark S
Recent News & Updates
Understanding Life Insurance Beneficiaries: How to Choose and When to Update
July 22, 2026
Commercial Auto Insurance: What Business Owners Should Know About Covering Company Vehicles
July 19, 2026
Renters Insurance: The Affordable Coverage Most Renters Don’t Know They’re Missing
July 16, 2026
Start Saving Today
Erie Insurance has been providing the protection you need and the service you expect, all at a great price. See why more than 90% of customers stay with Erie Insurance year after year.
Get an Auto QuotePay Your BillLife Insurance CalculatorAccess Online AccountERIE's YourTurn® Program
There is a new way Erie Insurance is looking out for you and wants to help you stay safe on the road.
Learn More
Contact John W. Neighbarger Insurance Agency
Let one of our experts customize a solution that’s right for you.
